The Cleveland Cavaliers’ playoff run in 2025 felt like a dream that turned into a nightmare in the Eastern Conference semifinals.
The Indiana Pacers delivered a stunning performance that caught nearly everyone off guard, taking the series 4-1 against the top-seeded Cavaliers.
Despite entering the postseason as the number one seed in the East, Cleveland couldn’t contain an Indiana squad that many had written off.
Analyst Matt Fontana was among those who underestimated the Pacers, and he’s now openly admitting he was in the wrong.
“Now, here’s the thing, I was coming from I didn’t think the Pacers were very good, so it could open up a window where I was wrong, and they are good, and I’m not smart for downplaying them. I actually think it bothers me even more. I will fully admit this: Tyrese Haliburton is a really good player, and the Pacers are a good team. [The Cavs] still should’ve beaten them in that series,” Fontana said.
After Games 1 and 2 of the ECF, do you feel differently about the #Cavs loss to the #Pacers? #LetEmKnow
"You still should've beaten them in that series."
– @MattFontana83 pic.twitter.com/apRwqfyIKn
— Matt Fontana Show (@MattFontanaShow) May 24, 2025
Injuries played a massive role in Cleveland’s downfall. Key stars Darius Garland and Donovan Mitchell both missed critical games, and even after returning, neither looked completely healthy.
Their limited impact showed during crucial moments when the Cavaliers needed them most.
The Pacers, meanwhile, displayed impressive depth and composure throughout the series. Tyrese Haliburton took control in Game 5, finishing with 31 points, eight assists, and six rebounds in a commanding performance that sealed Cleveland’s fate.
For the Cavaliers, this series exposed serious concerns. Their once-reliable three-point shooting disappeared, hitting just 26 percent from beyond the arc in the elimination game.
They also struggled to match Indiana’s aggressive defense and quick tempo.
The focus now shifts to recovery and preparation for next season. Cleveland’s core is expected to remain intact, and with a healthy roster, they’ll likely enter next season with championship expectations once again.
NEXT: Insider Believes Cavs' Mental Toughness Falls On Kenny Atkinson
